Thursday, January 27, 2011

AN EXPLOITATION OF MISCONCEPTIONS


First of all, let me express my deep regret to the precious lives that we have lost in this month's stampede at Sabarimala, Kerala. This mind-numbing incident should be an eye opener to Indian society. Here, exploitation of certain misconceptions have created a recipe for an unfortunate tragedy. This incident raises a very serious question - why would the authorities and ordinary people behave in such a highly irresponsible manner, risking the lives of self /others?

It is a very clear fact that such a massive crowd is nothing unusual in Sabarimala during this time of the year, because of the "Makara Vilakku" festival. Pilgrims come from all across South India to see the “Holy Fire”. It is clearly a rational thought that such a fire cannot appear at the same place at the same time every year unless it is man-made. Then, why are the pilgrim not using their intellect? Because, they get an assurance that "God" exists on seeing this “miracle” every year. Which is this God they are seeking for? The answer is written right on top of the temple entrance for everyone to see - "Tatvamasi" (it is you). This divinity called "God" that one comes to seek in the temple is nowhere other than in oneself and for that matter everywhere else. People are gettting more and more educated and exposed to rational thinking, but still vested interests want to maintain "special effects" to capitalize on their misconceptions and increase more crowds to make more money, just as how a retail outlet would behave. Just remember that the government monitoring and controlling the temple authorities is "Communist". Even if it is not, it makes no difference as its all boils down to greed and exploitation. 

It is not just the exploiters that are responsible, it is the exploited too. Society has become insensitive to the concern of others, and other people's rights are trampled upon by misusing freedom. The same applies here too. It is common knowledge, even for those who have not gone to Sabarimala that the crowd there is beyond controllable limits at this time of the year. But still, people go there in huge numbers and thus prepare the ground for such disasters to occur. There is a limit to which authorities, within their constraints can manage such a huge influx of devotees. The result is there for all to see.

It would be a pity for a society proud of claiming to be the heirs of an intellectually wealthy civilization to repeat the same mistake again. What is now required is a massive attempt to de-mythologize and de-mystify the traditional knowledge that this nation possesed, and spread its awareness among people, so that that all of the so-called superstitions ( I would say rather "misconceptions") will be replaced by true knowledge. There are and there will always be those who are infatuated with the crores and crores that the "pilgrimage" industry generates and seeks to exploit public misconceptions.

This sacrifice of valuble human life is not worth it. 



10 comments:

  1. Interesting blog.

    Sacrifice of human life is not worth any amount of faith. That is something I would agree to wholeheartedly.

    Rationality has its limits though. Faith has its benefits. I feel that the demystifying process of the vast heritage requires much more than rationality based on an opinionated knowledge, and that which is based purely on mass-consensus. Out of such an understanding though, what would emerge would be intelligent inheritors of the wisdom of the ancients. It would require much more than what is purely rational though, as it involves direct subjective experience and investigation of the individual himself ( as is the case in accruing benefits of yoga)

    That being said, the mishap shouldn't have happened in the first place. It is a shame that none is ready to look within themselves to give life to the principle "thattvamasi", but would be willing to fall prey to fear and stampede and kill innocents in the process.

    Nice blog. Should write a discussion of these ideas in a separate blog :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thank you...
    "intelligent inheritors of the wisdom of the ancients"...I like it...thats how we should be!

    ReplyDelete
  3. nice one..kooduthalayi ezhuthuka..update cheyumbol ene ariyikanam

    ReplyDelete
  4. great thought n good expression... being a person having close relations with these stuff i would better blame the authorities for the mishap.. but when we come across the subject of "misconceptions"..hmm... its a vast subject even highly inflammable..from my childhood am closely related to devaswomboard.. i mean ..coming from a family in mwhich most of the members are devaswom employees.. so commenting on that..see these misconcepts are questionable byproducts of our own intellect..." rajju sarpa branthi"(misunderstanding a rope 2 be a snake) ability to distinguish between real and unreal..these are being elborated in indian philosophic books such as "sankhya darshana"etc..if possible go through that would be very helpful..ok will come back with more contributions..bye fr nw.. anand keep going ..and thanks for this initiative...

    ReplyDelete
  5. HI Anand, This is rajiv cousin brother of deepthi chechi from KK dist, TN. She had mailed us this blog
    "It would be a pity for a society proud of claiming to be the heirs of an intellectually wealthy civilization to repeat the same mistake again". Yes WE are the heirs and we must try not to repeat the same mistake!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello Anand! A blog post which made me think a lot (after very long time - i should say :) )! I found another post on the same topic written from a different perspective. Pls have a look at it! :)

    http://www.yentha.com/news/view/5/2383

    Good luck and keep writing! :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks Vijar and Rakesh for your valuble comments...

    ReplyDelete